Anthony Richardson

As we approach the 2025 fantasy football season, Anthony Richardson is a name that sparks both excitement and caution. The young quarterback for the Indianapolis Colts is poised to compete with Daniel Jones for the starting job, a battle that will be closely watched during training camp. Despite his potential, Richardson's path to becoming a fantasy standout is not without its challenges. Recently, he underwent shoulder surgery, which has forced him to miss minicamp and could impact his readiness for the start of the season.

Richardson's fantasy value is heavily tied to his ability to secure the starting role. If he emerges victorious in the quarterback competition, he becomes a worthwhile late-round pick in all fantasy leagues. His rushing prowess is a significant factor in his fantasy appeal; in 2024, he demonstrated the ability to score at least 22.2 fantasy points in four out of ten healthy games, showcasing his potential for high fantasy output.

However, Richardson's passing skills remain a concern. With a career completion percentage of just 50.6%, he is flawed as a passer, which has led to inconsistent fantasy performances. In 2024, he had weeks where he ranked as high as QB10 but also plummeted to QB20 or worse in other weeks. This volatility makes fantasy players cautious about relying on him unless he can show significant improvement, particularly after working with a private quarterback coach who has helped other quarterbacks like Josh Allen.

The Colts have bolstered their offense with new additions, including tight end Tyler Warren, who was picked in the first round of the NFL Draft. This, combined with a solid receiving corps featuring Michael Pittman, Josh Downs, and Alec Pierce, provides Richardson with the tools he needs to succeed if he can secure the starting job. While his injury and past inconsistencies make him a risk, his upside, especially in his rushing ability, makes him a compelling pick for those willing to take the gamble.

Updated 06/28/2025